A red front door is one of the only places on a house where the paint is allowed to be the loudest thing in the picture, and that's exactly why it works. The eight picks here cover a wide spread within one family: Cinnamon Slate (Benjamin Moore 2113-40) sits at LRV 19, a soft, dusty red with almost as much brown and mauve in it as red, while Caliente (Benjamin Moore AF-290) and Million Dollar Red (Benjamin Moore 2003-10) drop to LRV 8, fully saturated and unmistakably red from the sidewalk. A door only has to answer to the house behind it, not a whole room full of furniture, so it can go bolder than almost anything else you'll paint.
The picks split into a few real camps, not just light-to-dark. Sunset Orange (Behr BXC-39) and Red Tomato (Sherwin-Williams SW 6607) lean warm and earthy, closer to terracotta than fire-engine red, so they read approachable rather than dramatic — a good fit for craftsman, cottage, or brick-adjacent homes where a true red would fight the trim. Cottage Red (Benjamin Moore HC-184) is the true, historic barn-red that's been the default "red door" color for decades; it's the safe, recognizable choice. Raspberry Truffle (Benjamin Moore 2080-10), Million Dollar Red, and Caliente all go deep and saturated — these are the doors people slow down to look at, and Caliente in particular shows up again and again as the most-picked Benjamin Moore red for entry doors.
Rosy Apple (Benjamin Moore 2006-30) is the outlier of the group. At LRV 15 it reads more pink-red than true red, cheerful rather than commanding, so it fits a homeowner who wants red's warmth without the weight of Cottage Red or the intensity of Caliente. None of these eight are pastel — front-door reds don't get much lighter than the high teens on the LRV scale — so the real decision isn't light versus light, it's muted versus saturated, and warm-orange versus true red.
Ask a Question